877-240-1181Apply
If you've built a book of business as a W-2 broker, the real question is what that same book would pay you as an independent agent — and what changes when you own it.
A W-2 freight broker is an employee: you earn a salary plus a commission plan, use your employer's carriers, technology and back office, and the customers belong to the employer. An independent freight agent owns their book and customers, earns a much larger share of gross profit (with Armstrong, up to 75%), and runs on a brokerage's infrastructure — trading a salary and benefits for ownership, higher upside and long-term business value.
| W-2 Freight Broker | Armstrong Agent | |
|---|---|---|
| Base salary | Usually | No — you run a business |
| Commission | Capped comp plan, typically lower | Up to 75% of gross profit |
| Income upside | Limited by the plan | Scales with your book |
| Employment | W-2 employee | 1099 independent |
| Benefits | Employer-provided | You arrange your own |
| Customer ownership | Belongs to the employer | Yours, contractually |
| Technology / TMS | Employer provides | Armstrong provides |
| Carrier network | Employer provides | Armstrong provides (TL + LTL) |
| Billing & collections | Employer | Armstrong |
| Customer credit & bad debt | Employer | Armstrong carries the risk |
| Claims | Employer | Armstrong supports |
| Operating expenses | None personally | You have business expenses |
| Income volatility | Lower (salary cushion) | Higher — earnings track the book |
| Building a team | Rarely yours to build | You can hire under your agency |
| Long-term business value | None — it's a job | You're building an asset |
The honest trade: as an agent you give up a salary and employer benefits and take on your own business expenses and more income variability. In exchange you keep a far larger share of the gross profit you produce, own the customer relationships, and build something with lasting value. For brokers already producing meaningful gross profit, the upside of owning that book is usually the deciding factor.
This page is educational and is not legal or tax advice. Whether you can move specific customers depends on your individual employment, non-solicitation and non-compete agreements — have them reviewed by qualified counsel. "Agency gross commission" is not the same as personal take-home income; independent agents have business expenses, benefits and taxes that come out of it.
Model your current compensation against agency gross commission at 60–75%.
A W-2 broker is an employee who earns a salary plus a commission plan and uses the employer's carriers, technology and back office; the customers belong to the employer. An independent freight agent owns their book and customers, earns a much larger share of gross profit, and uses a brokerage's infrastructure — trading a salary and benefits for ownership and higher upside.
They can, because agent earnings scale with the gross profit of the book rather than a capped comp plan — with Armstrong, up to 75% of gross profit. Agents are independent, so gross agency commission is not the same as take-home pay: business expenses, benefits and taxes come out of it.
That depends on your specific employment, non-solicitation and non-compete agreements, which vary and should be reviewed by qualified counsel. This page is educational and is not legal advice.